Showing posts with label town hall. Show all posts
Showing posts with label town hall. Show all posts

Sunday, October 11, 2009

Facebook Page up for "Who is SHAPING your Digital Future?"



There is a Facebook page up for the East Coast 'alternative' Town Hall on citizen concerns over "just who is driving the Internet and where ? "

For the few people left in the world who are not on Facebook, (and I am one of them !) information on the October 26 evening panel & audience at the Dal Sub's fabled McInnes Room can be found here, here and here.

I've seen a lot of the well known bloggers put in that oh so uninformative 'here, here and here' in their posts and I thought I give it a whirl, just this once.

PS : The place only holds 600, so plan to get there early - doors actually opens at 6:30 pm, for a 7:00 to 9:30 pm event.....

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Canada needs new Adult Education Movement as we struggle with Internet

(originally published in the Arcadian Recorder)

For Laura (Harman) Murray , being the keynote speaker at the October 26th Town Hall on citizen internet concerns ("Just Who is SHAPING your Internet Future ?") atDalhousie University's McInnes Room, will be a bit of a homecoming.

Her grandfather, Leonard Harman, got an honorary doctorate from Nova Scotia's St FxUniversity, home to Moses Coady's AntigonishMovement, for his many decades of labour on behalf of co-operatives and rural development & peace, in Canada and world wide.

But Harman remains best remembered today for his pioneering work in an early forerunner to today's interactive/two way internet : Canada's own unique contribution to adult education, the Farm Radio Forum.

The Farm Radio Forum, Canada's method of fostering two-way interactivity in mass citizen involvement, (on CBC Radio between 1939 to 1965), was taken up by the UN and introduced in many countries around the world.

It also had other Canadian spin-offs : the Labour Radio Forum and the Citizens Radio Forum (which survives to this day on CBC Radio as Rex Murphy's Cross Country Check-up.)

During the war years, gasoline was rationed and in any case, back rural roads weren't usually plowed in the winter .

Most rural communities had no electricity and were lucky if one or two richer families had a decent battery-powered radio.

The cooperative and adult education movements, flamed into life by the fiery speeches of Moses Coady, were going strong at that time (part of a broader wartime reform movement that led to the 1943 breakthrough for the CCF).

Adult education froze in the winter

Going strong, despite gas rationing, but only in the summer.

The Farm Radio Forum format emerged gradually.

Initially, the leaders of the co-op/adult education movement thought only of using the national radio network of the CBC (itself more or less brand new in 1939) to 'leap over' theunplowed snow-filled back roads to talk totheir rural members.

But without any way for field workers to visit in the winter, how could they be sure anyone was listening and if what they heard actually helped in their local situation?

The broadcasts were weekly and even in the wartime winter, mail could be relied upon ,in those days, to go to and from Ottawa to the remotest farming parts of (southern) Canada in a week.

Ottawa sent out - by mail - a weekly list of questions for the local group to debate after they listened , in someone's kitchen, to the weekly half hour radio panel discussion.

So far, pretty routine adult education stuff.

The Flash of Genius

But then the flash of genius sparked forth, perhaps driven by wartime necessity, because the CBC of 1940 was hardly a populist, bottom-up, sort of organization !

'Still isn't ?' Well, opinions vary.

Anyway, the Ottawa organizers dreamed up a way to ensure that the local meeting secretaries continued to send in their expected weekly summing-up of the local meeting's debate, without needing a field worker to drop in physically to chide them in person.

Why not tell the local meeting that their secretaries' comments would be summed in Ottawa and reported back to the national farm audience on the radio, with direct quotes from the most striking and vivid reports ?

A tempting prospect indeed for local farm notables who never expected to be quoted publicly at any higher level than their local community weekly's pages !

Radio broadcasting was an 'old' novelty by 1940, but a nation-wide broadcast by a interconnected network was still new and literally mind-blowing.

It was hard to believe that you, as an ordinary rural resident, could have lived long enough to expect to hear your written own words - delivered live by the miracle of radio - being broadcast into the homes of farmers andurbanites all across the nation simultaneously.

Remember, in those days, before our multi-channel world, there was a realistic chance that all your scattered family and friends country wide would in fact be listening to the CBC on a local affiliate station.

Wow !

For the first time ever in Canada, the big city experts on the radio had to listen to the voices of the 'little people' and had to adjust their own voiced opinions - live - as they heard the grassroots speak of their real world/ first hand experiences.

The Year 2009 : Progress ?

Cut to Halifax, 2009. The big people are still talking down - one way - to the little people - even on something that should be intrinsicallytwo way - like the Internet.

In August 2009, federal Industry Minister Tony Clement has a cosy private roundtable in Halifax on his proposed copyright act changes.

These roundtables are always intimate affairs , posted with signs saying 'general public keep out'. But at their best, they include representatives of both citizens and of industry and the conversation is two way and probing.

But Clement's Halifax meeting was with industry only.

Many Maritimers felt the Minister would not dare try this sort of thing in Central Canada , where there are well organized activist groups on behalf of the public good in matters digital.

What this region lacked was a meeting space where all the people concerned about just where the internet was going, could say their piece in a two way/ live communication with Internet experts.

A Farm Radio Forum, in other words !

And who better to invite to keynote the discussion than the granddaughter of Leonard Harman, herself a long time activist
in seeing that the general public's wider interests in an open, financially-accessible and neutral Internet were not overshadowed by the specific demands of Internet creators and users ?

At first glance, Laura (Harman) Murray might seem to be too much a pillar of the canadianacademic establishment
to be leading a citizen's movement for reclaiming a role for the general public on theinternet.

She has a PhD from Cornell, was a visiting Fulbright scholar and is a tenured English professor on one of Canada's elite universities, Queens. Her book on Canadian copyright law,
"Canadian Copyright, a Citizen's Guide" , is the standard text on the subject in most reference libraries.

Like many academics these days, she has a blog,

Unlike most academic blogs, her blog posts are not only informed and informative , they are also lively , readable, prose and above allpassionate.

It seems to run in her family, if her great auntMae , a feisty seniors activist extraordinaire, was anything to go by.

Laura hopes to move Canadians into action with her blogs, her articles and her public talks.

Her reoccurring theme?

That internet copyright,access, neutrality and privacy are not just something for experts. They are not even just something for activists.

Increasingly all of us are being forced to get pro-active on these issues because we are finding our hitherto ordinary and accepted daily activities hemmed in and restricted by copyright laws and internet provider policies that seem to act as if every citizen is guilty of something until proven innocent.

Murray comes across restrictions every day in her ordinary (non-professor) life : in what her local school board lets her kids copy for their projects to what SOCAN lets her play on her cello or banjo in her band, The Swamp Ward Orchestra.

Once again, Canadians need an adult education process to better inform ourselves about our rights and the issues as our world changes drastically from the one we grew up with, thanks to the digital revolution.

Nova Scotia, home to Moses Coady'sAntigonish Movement, just feels like thehistorically appropriate place to start.....

Thursday, September 24, 2009

cosy industry-only roundtables replaced by 600 citizens roaring : digital concerns heat up

a cross-post from the Arcadian Recorder:


Looming Digital Copyright/DRM/Net Neutrality/Privacy Law changes have a way of making all of Canada's citizens feel a bit like a criminal, if they dare try anything out of the ordinary on the internet.

Citizens , 'voters' in politico-speak, want their say on these issues - in person and in depth, just like 'the suits' are used to.

By and large, they aren't getting that chance.

The government's claim that it would be more open on this round of proposed amendments to the Copyright Law finally boiled down to a total of two token town hall meetings with the public.

The two, one in Montreal and one in Toronto, only drew flies - and were designed to do just that.

Halifax got only a particularly one-sided private industry roundtable with Industry Minister Clement.

Now the Dalhousie Student Union and the local access-for-all internet provider, Chebucto, are about to hold a real town hall in Halifax.

The keynote speaker is Pippa Lawson of CIPPIC, who some have called 'the citizen's bulldog' , because of the David versus Goliath stand she and her little band of law students have taken against the federal government time and again to force them to do what the law demands they do.

It was Pippa and CIPPIC students whose complaint to the federal privacy commissioner forced the commissioner to move against Facebook over privacy concerns - a case that had had global implications.

DSU and Chebucto expect 600 to attend - not bad considering the GTA of Toronto is about twenty times as big as metro Halifax and Clement's own town hall in Toronto only got 300 people out and the town hall in Montreal drew 100.

The venue is the Dal Student's fabled McInnes Room, a hall that has hosted just about every PM and political leader in Canada at some time or other over the last 41 years.

If an election call does happen in the next little while, the date of their town hall, October 26th,could fall right in the election period .

Interesting, because if any one issue is likely to get the non-voting youth out in droves at the ballot box, it would be the thought that the government is about to make it easy to send young people to jail for downloading tunes off Bit Torrent.

Critics charge that the Harper Tories are choking innovation and any chance at creating new interesting jobs for young people when they propose regressive copyright changes that only shield dinosaur industries from having to face new digital realities.

Just imagine : an election fought over fostering innovation, with the Conservatives on the 'nay' side.

Could be interesting...

Thursday, September 17, 2009

a town hall without the TOWN, isn't ( a town hall)


(If it wasn't for Michael Geist, I'd never even have heard of this marvel of mental furniture - a round table that is one sided, -------now read on:)

''Tony Clement - as only he can do it - in the role of the legendary Hank Williams - in ' The Halifax Town Hall He Never Gave ' ''

The October 26th Town Hall at the Dal SUB's fabled McInnes Room, over citizen concerns that the direction the Internet is heading towards is 'away from them', is a chance to address a great wrong.

On August 10th this year, federal Industry Minister Tony Clement slipped into Halifax to conduct a private, invite only, roundtable over the direction any amendments
to its existing copyright law should take.

{ A note aside: the Big Lie in Canada's copyright debate is the century old constant refrain that our copyright law is hopeless 'out of date' and needs urgent updating (so let us not waste time with needlessly public discussions), so we will no longer be the laughing stock of the civilized world.

Actually we have always been talking-about and changing-about our copyright laws since the day they were first created. But all that change supposedly 'due to changing circumstances' , has in fact been exclusively in one general direction.

Always the rights of the creators and their publishers has been expanded and always the rights of the consumers of creativity has been reduced.

Remember how artificial and society-slash-government-created copyright law actually is: the makers of machine tools don't have a government law requiring the purchasers of those machine tools pay them further every time they use the tool - but radio stations pay every time they play a record they paid for.

Copyright Law is supposed to balance the interests of creators and consumers , not be the lap dog of creators and publishers.}

On his trip to Halifax, Minister Clement didn't try to hold a dangerous open,public, advertised, Town Hall ; as he might if he actually wanted 'consultations' with' the public'.

Town Hall always represent the danger that masses of real live unpaid consumers might overwhelm the voices of the handful of paid lobbyists arguing for more money for creators & publishers.

And 'public' means all this ends up happening on the TV sets of millions of other ordinary consumers as they watch the evening news.

Worse, he went on to do in Halifax what he won't have dared to do in bigger cities like Toronto, Vancouver or Montreal.

His invite-only roundtable excluded representatives of ordinary consumers, of libraries and of teachers.

If a 'round' table can ever be 'one-sided' the Halifax roundtable was just that. For some lucky invitees, (industry invitees of course) this was their second invite to this exclusive soiree.

Clement figured Halifax would take it.

It didn't and it won't.

Chebucto Community Net and the Dal Student Union decided to do it up right.

On October 26th, even Tony Clement in Ottawa is going to hear this city and this region roar.

In all likelihood, five hundred and seventy ordinary consumers will be there,to contrast with perhaps only thirty lobbyists for the creators & publishers, and it will all play out in front of the TV cameras, microphones and reporters' notepads.

In the cosy world of industry-to-government lobbying this is sort of like Balloting Day in a goneral election.

You know, that rare one day every four years, when the vote of a homeless person weighs in just as heavily in the minds of Official Ottawa as does that of multi millionaire like Conrad Black.

Oops !- maybe more so...

Mark 7pm Monday october 26th, Dal SUB McInnes Room on your calendar - this should be fun.